Jonathan's Mistletoe Diary

December 15, 2012

Blackcaps, mistletoe and Monty Don doesn’t know

Filed under: Uncategorized — Jonathan Briggs @ 7:28 pm
No he doesn't - Monty Don gets the answers wrong

No he hasn’t – Monty Don gets the answers wrong

The possible interaction between increasing overwintering Blackcaps and increasing spread of mistletoe In the UK is fascinating – and I’ve mentioned it in this blog several times.

The basic story is that Blackcaps, Sylvia atricapilla, have started overwintering in Britain in increasing numbers since the late 1980s, a few dozen at first but now 1000s.  And during the same time period mistletoe distribution seems to have subtly changed.  Basically there’s more and faster spread of mistletoe in eastern parts of the UK than there used to be.

This change in mistletoe might be due to climate change – studies suggest mistletoe will move east with predicted climate change.  Or it might be due to those blackcaps – one of the few birds that likes mistletoe berries – spreading berries more efficiently.  They tend to ‘plant’ every seed by wiping it off their beaks on to a branch, whereas thrushes – our only other regular mistletoe eater, consume the berries whole and excrete the seeds, with most missing a branch.

I thought this story was relatively well-known by now, and have referred to it this season in articles for the RHS and the Society of Biology.

So I was surprised today to find Monty Don, in the Daily Mail today, claiming that he has the answers to mistletoe distribution.  According to him;

  • it occurs in its core area (the SW midlands/welsh border) because that’s where blackcaps migrate to – which is utter nonsense, not least because it’s been in this core area for hundreds of years and our overwintering blackcaps have only been here a few decades at most.  And they overwinter across much of Britain, not just in the SW midlands.
  • the blackcaps all come from Siberia – which they don’t – they come from Germany and adjoining areas and are a well-studied sub-race for which there are several recent scientific papers
  • they excrete the seed – er, no they don’t Monty. Mistle Thrushes excrete the seed. Blackcaps wipe the beak. How can you get that wrong?

Monty says he knows all this as the result of a new study – I wish I knew what ‘new study’ – as his critical facts are completely untrue. The impact of Blackcaps will be that mistletoe core area is blurred and widened – they don’t/won’t define it, they potentially ruin it.  He couldn’t have got it more wrong. But the references to blackcaps and mistletoe and new studies do imply he’s heard something – perhaps a chinese-whisper version of the real story and just extrapolated it randomly? He should have access to the account in RHS’s The Garden, perhaps he should read it.

Mr Don has written some nonsense about mistletoe before – but this article headed ‘Monty knows the answers’ really is an insult to the Mail’s readership.  He gets paid for this?  The Mail should be asking for their money back.

.

PS and don’t get me started on his weird statement about doubts whether seeds can survive birds’ digestive systems – how do you think seeds from berries are distributed in general Monty?  That’s what berries are FOR – to be eaten by grazing birds and animals who then excrete the definitely-still-live seeds elsewhere. That’s the whole basis of why plants have berries…. Sigh…

Advertisements

4 Comments »

  1. Great post really enjoyed your slightly irritated tone! 🙂 But it doesn’t surprise my nature conservationist husband who is constantly underwhelmed by peoples knowledge of their native flora and fauna. And don’t get him started about gardeners! – even though I used to be one!

    Comment by thinkingcowgirl — December 18, 2012 @ 8:09 pm | Reply

  2. Love to find examples of Monty being wrong yet again.

    Comment by rogerbrook — November 22, 2013 @ 8:45 am | Reply

  3. […] Monty’s at it again! His annual mistletoe misinformation project is reduced to one small paragraph this year, published as usual in that bastion of misinformation, the Daily Mail. For comment on one of his longer previous efforts have a look at the the Mistletoe Diary for Dec 15th last winter. […]

    Pingback by Monty’s annual mistletoe misinformation | Jonathan's Mistletoe Diary — December 29, 2013 @ 10:24 am | Reply

  4. How could Monty Don get things so wrong – and why would he write in the mail of all papers! ‘Experts’ eh!
    10 years ago I cut mistletoe from a garden 3 miles away (where it was overwhelming an apple tree) and hung bunches opposite the kitchen window to see what they would attract. A female blackcap appeared in early January and stayed with us until late March. She ate numerous mistletoe berries and plenty of apples too (halved and wired to a bird table) but never touched the fat or seed/peanuts nearby.
    A couple of years ago we noticed a young mistletoe plant growing on a Cotoneaster in the garden. It could only have been the blackcap that ‘set’ the seed since we hardly ever get mistle thrushes in the garden.
    This winter (2014/15) we have had a male blackcap who has eaten many different foods but so far not one of the 200+ mistletoe berries on the bunch now hanging up opposite the kitchen window.
    Nick Brown, near Derby.
    Ps. If you want to see a superb photo of a mistle thrush with a mistletoe berry in its beak, taken in Worcestershire by John Robinson, search Surfbirds’ photo gallery called ‘Britain and Europe Common’.

    Comment by Nick Brown — January 4, 2015 @ 11:03 am | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: